plants divider
September 9, 2022 9:00

Why Shouldn’t You Accept a Counteroffer from The Standpoint Of A Recruiter?

Ashley Huang
linkedin
/ashley-h-801858141/
content writing

You've finally decided to start looking for a new career and new opportunities. You've submitted your CV and portfolio to various job-search websites, you went through multiple job interviews, and finally, you received an offer that you are totally prepared to accept.

Getting a call from the prospective hiring manager and he/she informs you with the following sentence:

 “Congratulations! We like you to be part of our team. We would like to offer you a salary of$XXXX for the job role that you have applied for. Would you be keen to take on this role and further your career with our organization?”

 

This line alone can elicit a variety of feelings, including excitement, happiness, or even a sigh of relief that the process is over. However, after working in the recruiting industry for many years, I have seen several instances when candidates phone us a few hours or days later to say they have gotten a counteroffer from their current employer. To be honest, this is not an ideal situation for you. Usually, counteroffers do not end nicely. Accepting a counteroffer can be challenging, and there are several aspects to consider. Your decision is likely to have a considerable influence on your career, so consider it wisely.

 

Let me briefly describe to all of you,

 

‘What is a Counteroffer?’

 

 A counteroffer is typically made in reaction to another offer. If you receive a salary offer of $7,500 from a prospective employer, your present employer may match it or offer you a 10% to 20% raise on top of your current income. I agree that resigning from your current employment requires a lot of courage. The notion of informing your upper management and informing him/her that you intend to resign may be emotionally draining, especially given that you must stay on for the following 1-3 months of notice time depending on your job position.

 

Keep in mind, however, that if you express your wish to leave and your employer decides to give you a counteroffer in order to keep you, and you say yes, this decision might be one of the worst in your career.

 

 

You have a reason for wanting to quit

 

The grounds behind the counteroffer are more complex than they appear at first glance.Before accepting the counteroffer, look in the mirror and ask yourself,"Why do I want to resign?" There are various reasons why you may wish to quit in the first place. It might be that you are bored and dissatisfied with your current salary, or that you have a negative connection with your coworkers and supervisor. However, even if your counteroffer meets your demands in the short term. It won't be long before you quit once more.

 

Consider whether the counteroffer addresses the core reasons for your resignation. If it doesn’t, you’re far more likely to be holding for a new job soon, and may be regretting the option to pass up the other offer.

 

Lack Of Trust

 

No matter how well you get along with your boss and coworkers, if you say yes to a counteroffer in response to your resignation, your loyalty will be called into question in the future. Even if the work provides potential for career advancement, you are unlikely to be the first person chosen during the promotion period. Your employer probably will be expecting you to resign anytime soon as they are unsure how long you will stay with them.

 

There have been several cases when individuals accepted my clients’ offer in Base CampRecruitment, only for them to accept a counteroffer from their current employment at the very last minute. I acknowledge that it is frustrating from a recruiter’s perspective, but I understand why these applicants say yes nonetheless, you must consider whether your employer and coworkers would trust you after this ordeal. I'm afraid the answer is no in most cases.

 

 

No Chance for Career Progression

 

Let's give this some thought. Firstly, if you had opted to leave, your company may not even consider granting you a raise in the future if you accept the counteroffer in the current moment.  Although your employer may have battled hard to keep you from quitting, it might have an impact on your job security. There is a strong possibility that we are entering a worldwide recession, so what are the odds that they will keep you if your company suffers a significant loss in the future?

 

Secondly, you've probably begun looking for a new job because you felt mistreated and constrained, or you simply want that salary boost you believe you deserve. Many of my previous life experiences occurred as a result of the simple statement"There are no rewards without risks." This term, I believe, significantly correlates with accepting or rejecting a counteroffer.

 

It might be along time before you receive another raise. Please exercise caution when submitting resignations as we do not want you to be in any 'counteroffer' scenarios.

 

 

In general, you should receive a counteroffer within a day or two if you ever receive one.I strongly believe that you should politely tell your current employer that you appreciate them for the offer and briefly speak all about the positive experiences in the job.

 

However, if you have ever considered resigning and you start applying for a new employment, just quit for greener pastures if they offer a higher wage or more work flexibility. Always keep in mind that accepting a counteroffer at your current employer may result in unfavourable consequences. It can be a horrible experience when your coworkers doubt your loyalty, and you may feel as though you work in a toxic workplace.

 

Whenever you are feeling low at your workplace, you will feel that you can never deliver100% on the job and you will have low motivation to achieve more in your employment. I do not want you or anyone to have a low morale at work.

 

 

Related articles

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Exploring the Evolving IT Employment Landscape in Asia: Opportunities and Challenges

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Exploring the Crucial Role of Data Engineers in Today's Tech-Driven Business Environment

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Evaluating Micro-Credentials in Tech Recruitment – What Recruiters Really Check For

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

From Code to Clinic: IT Careers in Healthcare Innovation

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Exploring the Role of Career Guidance Services in Navigating the IT Job Market in Asia-Pacific

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

GitHub Guru: How to Make Your GitHub Profile Shine and Attract Recruiters

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

How Personal Projects Elevate Your IT Recruitment Game

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Enhancing Your Employment Value Proposition: A Key Strategy for Attracting Top IT Talent in the Asia-Pacific Region

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

How to Land a Cloud Engineer Role with No Experience

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

How to Transition from a Junior Developer to Senior Developer

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Logic Puzzles for Programmers: Sharpen Your Problem-Solving Skills for Assessments

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Mastering Tailored Recruitment Strategies: A Guide for IT Companies in the Asia-Pacific Region

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Mastering IT Recruitment: 7 Essential Takeaways for Tech Professionals

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Mastering Tech Talent Acquisition in the Asia-Pacific Region: Strategies for Success

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Mastering the Art of Tech Talent Acquisition: Strategies for Sourcing and Retaining the Best in Singapore

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Mastering the Art of Cyber Resilience: Essential Strategies for Effective Risk Assessment and Management

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Optimizing Your LinkedIn Profile for Landing a Tech Job

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Enhancing IT Recruitment: The Power of Community Involvement and Social Responsibility

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Empowering Your Cybersecurity Strategy: The Advantages of Virtual vCISO Services with RiskAware

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Revolutionizing IT Recruitment: The Importance of Boutique Services in Today's Tech-Driven World

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Revolutionizing IT Recruitment: Streamlining the Hiring Process for Enhanced Efficiency in Tech Companies

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Rapid Onboarding: Strategies to Get Tech Workers Up to Speed in Record Time

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Soft Skills in Tech Hiring: Expert Approaches to Identifying Impactful Communicators

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Salary Negotiation in Tech: The Science Behind Closing the Deal with Top Candidates

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Revolutionizing IT Recruitment: The Power of Personalized Hiring Services

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Strategically Allocating Your IT Budget to Mitigate Cybersecurity Risks: Insights from RiskAware

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Streamlining IT Recruitment in Asia-Pacific: The Future of Tech Hiring

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Empowering Cyber Resilience: How Automation Enhances RiskAware's Cyber Security Solutions

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Tech Stacks That Are Killing Your Hiring Chances (And What Recruiters Are Actually Looking For)

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Decoding Client Culture: A Crucial Aspect of IT Recruitment Success

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Building Strong IT Networks: The Importance of Aligning Values in Tech Recruitment

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Avoiding Costly Cyber Attacks: The Role of Secure SMTP in Your Email Strategy

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

AI on the Assembly Line: How Automation is Transforming Manufacturing Careers

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Advanced DevOps Screening: Insider Techniques for Evaluating High-Performing Candidates

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

A Step-by-Step Guide to Nailing Your Job Interview

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

The One Technical Question That Instantly Separates Senior Engineers from Juniors

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

The 6-Month Software Engineering Challenge: A Fun Guide to Launch Your Tech Career

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

The Real Cost of a Bad Developer Hire—and How to Avoid It

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

The Tech Talent Gap: Why Finding the Right Developer Is Harder Than Ever and How to Solve It

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

The STAR Method: Master the Art of Answering Behavioral Interview Questions in IT

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Top 5 Benefits of Implementing Real-Time Phishing Protection for Your Organization

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Top 5 Phone Interview Questions for IT Job Seekers

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Top 5 Interview Techniques for Hiring Exceptional Programmers

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Top IT Recruitment Strategies to Secure Elite Talent in the Asia Pacific

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Top Micro-Credentials Changing Tech Recruitment: What You Need to Know

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Unlocking the Future of Tech: Strategies for Sourcing and Retaining Top IT Talent in the Asia Pacific

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Unlocking the Potential of Tech Talent in the Asia Pacific Region

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Unlocking Your Potential: Essential Tips for Career Development in IT

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Why Companies Are Moving from Monolith to Microservices—And What It Means for Your Career

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/
Apr 29, 2025 9:36 AM

Using Voice-to-Text Technology for Agile Onboarding Documentation

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Exploring the Crucial Role of Data Engineers in Today's Tech-Driven Business Environment

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Exploring the Evolving IT Employment Landscape in Asia: Opportunities and Challenges

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Unlocking Success: Essential Skills Every Business Analyst Should Have

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Unlocking the Future of Tech: Strategies for Sourcing and Retaining Top IT Talent in the Asia Pacific

James Goodwin
James Goodwin
linkedin
/jamesgoodwin1981/

Enhancing Your Employment Value Proposition: A Key Strategy for Attracting Top IT Talent in the Asia-Pacific Region

Luke Wang
Luke Wang
linkedin
/lukedavidwang/
Jun 22, 2023 1:00 PM

Optimizing Your LinkedIn Profile for Landing a Tech Job

Talitha Celsyah Tampi
Talitha Celsyah Tampi
linkedin
/talitha-celsyah-t-692619145/
Mar 7, 2023 11:45 AM

6 extraordinary tips on how you can foster a solid company culture as a hiring manager

Talitha Celsyah Tampi
Talitha Celsyah Tampi
linkedin
/talitha-celsyah-t-692619145/
Mar 2, 2023 11:00 AM

What impact does social media have in recruitment?

Frewain John
Frewain John
linkedin
/frewain-john-215a69bb/
Feb 24, 2023 11:10 AM

Top 5 ways to properly use Linkedin to effectively land your dream job

Ashley Huang
Ashley Huang
linkedin
/ashley-h-801858141/
Feb 23, 2023 11:45 AM

How can you ensure that your company is ready for Gen Z's?

Talitha Celsyah Tampi
Talitha Celsyah Tampi
linkedin
/talitha-celsyah-t-692619145/
Feb 14, 2023 11:00 AM

What does Valentine's Day have in common with IT Recruitment?

Frewain John
Frewain John
linkedin
/frewain-john-215a69bb/
Feb 6, 2023 4:20 PM

8 Tips On How You Can Increase Your Chance Of Being Headhunted

Ashley Huang
Ashley Huang
linkedin
/ashley-h-801858141/
Dec 12, 2022 1:00 PM

How Can You Ace Your Telephone Interview?

Frewain John
Frewain John
linkedin
/frewain-john-215a69bb/
meeting
Sep 9, 2022 9:00 AM

Why keywords are so important in a resume

Ashley Huang
Ashley Huang
linkedin
/ashley-h-801858141/
planing conversation
Sep 9, 2022 9:00 AM

What are the IT Industry Hiring Insights in the Post-Pandemic Era?

Frewain John
Frewain John
linkedin
/frewain-john-215a69bb/
meeting
Sep 9, 2022 9:00 AM

How should you prepare for your first round of interviews with potential employer?

right arrow
right arrow